Blue Hill Peninsula/
Deer Isle
Dining Spots

Arborvine
Main Street, Blue Hill

The chef who spearheaded the changes in Down East dining tastes a generation ago is back for an encore.

John Hidake, who launched Blue Hill’s acclaimed Fire Pond restaurant in 1977 and led it through its glory years, and his wife Beth converted a rambling, 200-year-old Maine farmhouse on Tenney Hill into a fine-dining restaurant and headquarters for their Moveable Feasts catering service. Lately, they added the Vinery, a piano bar and bistro, open for light fare in what had been a deli/takeout shop at the rear of the property.

John had sold Fire Pond in 1987 because “we had achieved what we had set out to do” and he wanted to spend more time with his young family. “But I really missed the creativity of a restaurant kitchen, which you can’t do in the catering business.” He also missed his regular patrons, who had become close friends. His wide following missed him, too – in its earlier days, a trip to the Penobscot Bay area without a dinner at Fire Pond was unthinkable. All these factors conspired to prompt his return.

The new restaurant seats about 50 in two small front dining rooms and a larger, L-shaped room that doubles as a reception area and bar. Mismatched tables and chairs in the Shaker, Heppelwhite and Windsor styles are set with antique linens, flowers and votive candles. Oriental rugs dot the floors. Each dining area has a working fireplace and is furnished with antiques. John made some of the furniture himself.

The dinner menu features local seafood as well as heartier fare like rack of lamb with wild mushroom sauce and tournedos bordelaise. Seasonal dishes include broiled halibut with mushrooms and scallions in a green curry sauce, grilled yellowfin ahi tuna with ginger-soy aioli, amaretto-glazed duckling with apple-ginger chutney, medallions of pork with apples and calvados-maple glaze, and grilled sirloin steak with a five-spice rub and a cardamom-scented maitre d’ butter. The night’s specials might add treats like galettes of Maine crabmeat and shrimp with a light dijon sauce on a bed of herbed bulgur and grilled magret of moulard duck with a plum and mint salsa.

Typical appetizers are a medley of smoked salmon, trout and mussels with horseradish cream, brie in puff pastry with figs and toasted almonds, and a salad of baby beets, leeks and pears with gorgonzola. Specials could be a soup of chilled avocado with crème fraîche and a salad of strawberries, mango and melon with toasted pistachios and a prickly pear vinaigrette.

Dessert favorites include grand marnier chocolate mousse, white chocolate cheesecake with berries and lemon curd tartlets.

The Vinery, a brick-floored conservatory, offers pastas and light fare in the $9 to $14 range. It’s now run by the Hikades’ son Andrew, who cooks in a separate kitchen. Son Tim serves as sous chef in his father’s kitchen.

(207) 374-2119. www.arborvine.com. Entrées, $22 to $29. Dinner, Tuesday-Sunday 5 to 9:30, Friday-Sunday in winter. Vinery in season, Wednesday-Sunday 5 to 9.
 

The Wescott Forge
66 Main St., Blue Hill.

Also back for an encore is our beloved Fire Pond – this time, after several reincarnations under different owners, with a new name, a new look and an acknowledged nod to the Fire Pond tradition.

After Frenchman Jean-Paul Lecomte closed his nighttime Jean-Paul at the Fire Pond and his daytime Jean-Paul Bistro across the street, the Fire Pond building beside the millstream lay dormant until its rescue by Blue Hill resident Johnny Bravo and folks formerly associated with the late Thrumcap café and wine bar in Bar Harbor. Anneliese Riggall and chef Daniel Sweimler opened the Wescott Forge in 2005, with backing from Thrumcap owner Tom Marinke.

A substantial renovation on two floors of the old mill building created an elegant open dining area on the lower level seating 50 beside a gas fireplace. The tables of choice continue to be on a delightful enclosed porch beside the millstream, which is illuminated at night. Well-spaced tables dressed in white with beige overlays downstairs and an upstairs lounge with a bar and couches help create an easy elegance to the historic building, renamed for one of the last blacksmiths to occupy the structure. Touches of the old forge show up in the wrought-iron stair railing and light fixtures.

“We wanted to bring back what Blue Hill had lost,” Anneliese said of the move to Blue Hill, which coincided with the closing of Thrumcap. With her came New York-trained chef Dan, whom Tom Marinke described as “the best chef we ever had” in his years at Thrumcap and its predecessor, the Porcupine Grill.

Dan designed the Forge’s fare to be “progressive new French with Asian and Italian influences,” reflecting his New York background and local ingredients. He pledged to “keep it fresh – for myself, as well as for everybody else.”

His opening menu was short but sweet, the kind upon which almost everything appeals. It featured such entrées as poached halibut with salsa verde, seared seaweed-crusted hai    ???AHI    tuna with a wasabi-pea coulis, pork tenderloin with a plum glaze and grilled sirloin with a burgundy reduction. Starters included house-smoked mussels with jícama and mango curry, tuna tartare, a roasted beet and asparagus tart with goat cheese, a crisp spring roll with jonah crab and shiitake mushrooms, and a lobster salad with nectarines, watercress and pomegranate syrup. Desserts were a Schokinag chocolate soufflé with bourbon cream, strawberry-rhubarb shortcake with fromage blanc ice cream and Earl Grey crème brûlée. Also offered was a cheese plate with fruits and quince paste.

A rustic bar menu with smoked fish, terrines and charcuteries is available in the main-floor lounge. The short wine list is priced mainly in the high twenties and thirties.

(207) 374-9909. www.thewescottforge.com. Entrées, $17 to $23. Lunch, Monday-Saturday 11:30 to 3, Thursday-Saturday noon to 3 in winter. Dinner, Monday-Saturday 5:30 to 9:30, Wednesday-Saturday 4 to 9 in winter.  

  
 Whale's Rib Tavern
20 Main St., Deer Isle, ME

Some of the island’s best meals have long attracted the public as well as inn guests for dinner at the Pilgrim’s Inn. 

In 2005, the new owners renamed the restaurant the Whale’s Rib Tavern, added a second dining room next to the inn’s taproom and added an upscale tavern menu to their traditional offerings. 

The former goat barn has been refurbished to resemble a 1793 tavern, with windsor chairs at white-clothed tables. Well-known Maine chef Jonathan Chase has presided in the Pilgrim’s Inn kitchen since he sold his namesake Blue Hill restaurant in 2002. He and two other chefs offer up to 40 entrées nightly. 

Their tavern menu includes the likes of baby back ribs, meatloaf, bangers and mash, and shepherds pie.

 The traditional menu might start with Scandinavian-style borscht, parmigiano-reggiano flan with tomato-basil coulis and a smoked seafood sampler of mussels, Maine shrimp and Scottish salmon. Entrées range from a signature seafood stew and tuna niçoise to pan-seared venison medallions with a shiitake mushroom-red wine sauce.

 Desserts include chambord cheesecake and mocha mousse.

(207) 348-6615 or (888) 778-7505. Entrées, $11.95 to $34.95; tavern menu, $8.95 to $14.95. Dinner nightly, 4:30 to 10:30. Closed early January to early May.


The Maritime Café
27 Main St. , Stonington .

The harbor views outside the wraparound windows are a major attraction at this with-it establishment, run by an Austrian by way of Colorado .

Rudi Newmayr, a contractor who built many a restaurant but said this is the first he ever owned, took over the old Atlantic Café space in 2004 and added some interesting twists. He dispenses typical Maine fare, of course, but with a sophisticated flair. He also has an espresso and crêpe bar geared to the after-theater crowd from the Stonington Opera House and a barbecue grill outside serving up spicy German sausages.

For lunch, we sampled a spicy organic Colorado sausage sandwich after savoring a bowl of fishermen’s chowder in a fragrant saffron lobster broth. The oversize broiled haddock sandwich on a toasted bun also proved succulent.

The dinner menu ranges widely from roasted halibut with watermelon syrup and wasabi oil and sugar cane skewered tiger shrimp with pineapple salsa to herb-roasted chicken breast with truffle poultry jus and pistachio-crusted rack of lamb. Grilled duck breast with sweet potato hash and cranberry-fig relish and grilled venison chop with roasted plum barbecue sauce and Asian slaw were hits on the autumn menu.

You might start with steamed mussels with fennel, tomatoes and garlic in a white wine broth or seared quail in a lavender-honey glaze. Lobster might show up in a “B.L.T” – lobster layered between buffalo mozzarella and tomatoes. Finish with one of the specialty dessert crêpes.

With windows onto the water, the 28-seat dining room is simple but stylish with white paneling, wide-board flooring and benches imported from Colorado . The rope-wrapped wall sconces help convey a maritime look. An outdoor deck with umbrellaed tables beside the harbor is put into service at lunchtime. It proves an idyllic setting for the evening lobster bakes on summer weekends. A 1¼-pound lobster with mussels, corn on the cob and coleslaw was going for $19.95 at our latest visit.

(207) 367-2600. www.maritimecafe.com. Entrées, $18 to $24. Lunch daily, 11:30 to 2:30 . Dinner, 5:30 to 8:30 . BYOB. Closed November-April.

Lily's Cafe
Route 15, Stonington

Deer Isle and Stonington folks head for this inauspicious looking little house across the cove from South Deer Isle for what they consider consistently the best food around. Chef-owner Kyra Alex opened in 1998 and attracted a steady following for eclectic fare that ranges from lentil salad to cold Chinese noodles to crispy baked haddock sandwich to albacore tuna melt to veggie sandwich and Lily’s nutburger. That’s a sampling of the all-day fare.

At night, Kyra adds a couple of specials that she decides on at about 3 p.m. and are “ready at 5.” One night’s choices were baked salmon and polenta with chicken sausage and tomato sauce. The previous night saw white lasagna and baked pork with roasted potatoes and gravy. The main floor of the house holds six tables, most topped with glass and dolls or shells. Nine more tables in two upstairs rooms are pressed into service on busy nights.

The restaurant hews to limited hours, never on weekends and closing at 8 p.m. We know, because we were running late and nearly didn’t make it. But our innkeeper guests pulled rank and got us in for a convivial meal of delectable lamb chops, topped off with bread pudding.

Upstairs is the Chef’s Attic, a shop featuring cottage wares and occasional art shows. There also are tables scattered around the back lawn and an organic produce stand in this establishment that’s the essence of Down East Maine.

(207) 367-5936. Entrées, $5.95 to $10.95. Open Monday. Tuesday and Friday, 7 to 4, Wednesday and Thursday 7 to 8, Memorial Day through Labor Day. Closes one hour earlier rest of year.

 

Material excerpted from Getaways for Gourmets in the Northeast by Nancy and Richard Woodworth. Copyright 2006.

Wood Pond Press
365 Ridgewood Road
West Hartford, CT 06107
Phone: (860) 521-0389
Fax: (860) 313-0185
© Copyright 2008
All rights reserved.

E-mail feedback to:
woodpond@ntplx.net

Home page | Full destination index |
About Wood Pond Press | Ordering Information | Restaurant of the Week | Inn of the Week |
Book of the Month | Getaway of the Month |