Cooperstown
The All-American Village

By Nancy and Richard Woodworth

Few places its size (population, 2,200) are so embedded in the American consciousness as the upstate New York village of Cooperstown.

Native son novelist James Fenimore Cooper gave it and Otsego Lake, his “Glimmerglass,” a romantic place in the history of literature through his Leatherstocking Tales. Abner Doubleday supposedly invented the game of baseball here, and the Baseball Hall of Fame stands as the shrine to America's national pastime. The Farmers' Museum captures the spirit of New York State's rural life of the 19th century.

Although Cooper and Doubleday get most of the credit, the impetus for the Cooperstown we know today stemmed from latter-day native sons, the Clark family of Singer sewing machine fame. The house that Edward S. Clark built in 1932 on the Cooper property beside Otsego Lake is now the Fenimore Art Museum, a showcase for the New York State Historical Association's masterful collections of folk and decorative art. Stephen C. Clark Sr. paid $5 for an early baseball that led to the formation in 1939 of the National Baseball Hall of Fame. He founded the Farmers' Museum in 1943, the third prong in his visionary effort to develop for Cooperstown a clean industry, tourism. Another prong has emerged with the evolution of the Glimmerglass Opera, thanks to more local benefactors, the Busches of beer fame.

The three museums – celebrating baseball, art and rural life – reflect the essence of small-town America and inspire for Cooperstown the logical moniker, “The Village of Museums.” But Cooperstown is no mere display-case relic. It's the living Norman Rockwell town where oversize flower baskets hang from the downtown lampposts, flags fly in front of homes large and small along its tree-shaded streets, there's only one traffic light and, but for a new CVS pharmacy, no outside chain store or motel has been allowed to sully its all-American purity.

"Time has stood still here and people fight tooth and nail to keep it that way," says Laura Zucotti, the ex-New York restaurateur who opened the J.P. Sill House here as a B&B. And well they should. Cooperstown is a neat and tidy-looking community with an air of obvious prosperity. The Bassett Hospital, affiliated with Columbia University, is the village's biggest employer and a training site for doctors. The impressive Clark Sports Center is a multi-purpose counterpoint to baseball's historic Doubleday Field. Main Street is dominated by the institutional presence of the Hall of Fame and the lakeshore by the stately Otesaga resort.

The Otesaga, a few old inns and small up-the-lake motels monopolized visitor accommodations until 1984, when the first B&Bs emerged. That year, four pages in the 36-page Cooperstown Area Guide were devoted to accommodations. A decade later, the guide had swelled to 72 pages, 32 of them for lodgings – by 2002, 52 of the 112 pages were so dedicated.  Many were opened by former metropolitan New Yorkers who found nirvana here away from the mainstream.

Cooperstown, enveloped in hills, is not really on the way to anywhere else and therefore access is difficult. That helps explain its singularity, but scarcely prepares unsuspecting visitors for what they find – a picturesque, tranquil lakeside village that's far more than a baseball shrine. Here is a Brigadoon dreamland suspended in time.


Material excerpted from Inn Spots & Special Places / Mid-Atlantic,
by Nancy and Richard Woodworth. Copyright 2003.

Wood Pond Press
365 Ridgewood Road
West Hartford, CT 06107
Phone: (860) 521-0389
Fax: (860) 313-0185
© Copyright 2008
All rights reserved.

E-mail feedback to:
woodpond@ntplx.net

Home page | Full destination index |
About Wood Pond Press | Ordering Information | Restaurant of the Week | Inn of the Week |
Book of the Month | Getaway of the Month |