Cooperstown
Dining Spots

Hoffman Lane Bistro
2 Hoffman Lane, Cooperstown

Formerly the Terrace Café, this was reopened in 1999 by Mark Loewenguth, a New York Restaurant School alumnus. He was finishing a two-year assignment to launch the Fenimore Café and The Herder’s Cottage restaurants at the state museums when he met up with David Neil, a Culinary Institute of America grad who had helped open a downtown restaurant here. “It was serendipitous,” Mark said. “We both wanted to do our own restaurant and this building was available.” Their aim was to create an affordable, neighborhood-style restaurant – “the place where the locals go,” he said. A loyal year-round following testifies to their success.

The pair did most of the renovations themselves, painting three dining areas on three levels a soothing taupe with white trim and hanging the walls with the local photos of father-son photographers Milo Stewart Sr. and Jr. Striking colored glass bottles, obtained at a New York flea market, hold olive oil and serve as centerpieces on each table. White butcher paper atop the white tablecloths provides doodling areas for the crayons stashed at each table.

Regulars return again and again for the meatloaf, the chicken potpie and the spaghetti with meatballs and marinara sauce. But there’s far more than comfort food here. The pan-fried crab and crawfish cake with wilted spinach and creole mustard beurre blanc is a signature appetizer. Another good starter is maple-glazed lamb tenderloin on a skewer grilled with grapes and served over arugula with red pepper and blue cheese. Main courses range from tuna steak au poivre to boneless duck breast with ginger-orange glaze to coffee-encrusted ribeye steak finished with pepperwood pinot noir sauce. Dessert could be a classic crème brûlée, chocolate mousse cake or black raspberry cheesecake.

Similar inspiration mixes with the traditional on a lunch menu priced from yesteryear.

In season, customers spill from the main-floor bar area out onto a 50-seat dining terrace enclosed by a fence bearing grapevines hand-painted by a local artist.

(607) 547-7055. www.hoffmanlanebistro.com. Entrées, $12.95 to $19.95. Lunch daily in summer, 11:30 to 2:30 . Dinner nightly, 5 to 9 . Closed Sunday and Monday in off-season.

 The Blue Mingo Grill
West Lake Road (Route 80), Cooperstown

Among the area’s hottest seasonal dining tickets is this seasonal lakeside establishment with the odd name (taken, co-owner Michael Moffat says, from the local Indian tribe of Blue Mingo who appeared in the works of James Fenimore Cooper).

Featuring the creative grill cuisine of a chef from New York’s famed Arcadia Restaurant, this started simply in 1987 as a hot-dog stand called Dot’s Landing behind Sam Smith’s Boatyard, about two miles north of Cooperstown. The hot-dog stand’s founders, Sam Smith’s daughter Cory and husband Michael, now run the restaurant and boatyard (plus several retail ventures) in partnership with another daughter, Robin, and her husband Jaime Butchard.

 Here, two Adirondack-style dining porches open off the marina store. The Moffats polyurethaned the tables with local memorabilia, hung watery artifacts on the walls and dressed the place with linens and flowers at night. Diners look across the lake to the landmark Kingfisher Tower as they sample such starters as Indian griddled corn cakes with smoked salmon and sour cream, oven-roasted quail with grilled sweet potato and port, and wild mushroom and goat cheese napoleon.

The blackboard menu of contemporary/fusion fare changes twice a week. Expect main courses like grilled salmon with red pepper marmalade, grilled lobster with roast corn butter, roast duck with chipotle sauce, and coriander-crusted New York strip steak with oven-roasted tomatoes. House salads, grilled mixed vegetable skewers and roast garlic-mashed potatoes or house rice accompany. Key lime pie is a favorite dessert.

The lunch menu ranges from the Mingo Cuban sandwich and catch of the day on a kaiser roll with orange-wasabi tartar sauce to the Caribbean mango shrimp wrap, seafood salad and the boatyard dog, the hot dog that made Dot’s Landing famous.

(607) 547-7496. Entrées, $18.95 to $29.95. Lunch daily except Wednesday, 11:30 to 2:30 . Dinner daily except Wednesday, 5 to 10 . Closed Labor Day to Mother’s Day.

 The Hawkeye Bar & Grill
60 Lake St., Cooperstown

The casual American grill on the lower level of the Otesaga resort has leapt into the forefront of local dining favorites lately.

As compared with the fancy upstairs Dining Room and Lakeside Patio, which are considered special-occasion places and rather stodgy, the grill fare is more contemporary and the decor casual. It’s immensely popular with people who like the Otesaga cachet, the lakeside setting and the reasonable prices. They speak highly of such dinner entrées as Eastern salmon fillet with dill-cream sauce, grilled sea scallops with spinach-butter sauce, roast half duck with sundried cherry sauce or lamb chops with juniper berry-merlot sauce. You can settle for a burger, a sandwich, a caesar salad or a risotto, or graze on appetizers like an onion blossom, a trilogy of smoked seafood, or oriental pork dumplings. Sandwiches, salads and some of the dinner appetizers are available for lunch.

Like most resorts of its ilk, the Otesaga’s upstairs is a local favorite for a summer lunch or Sunday brunch on the outdoor terrace or in the beautiful, chandeliered dining room all in pristine white with red accents. We headed here for lunch, until we found they weren't serving outside on a mild September day and the lunch buffet in the dining room cost $14 for an array that looked like a glorified salad bar with seafood newburg, rice and green beans at the end.

The fancy setting lends itself less to a quick weekday lunch than to a leisurely Sunday brunch. The extra tab for brunch ($19) yields omelets, salad and meat platters, and steamship round, and the venue is usually on the outside terrace overlooking the lake.

The printed dinner menu (prix-fixe, $32) changes daily. Au courant choices are mixed in with traditional fare. They offer a range from fresh fruit cup with cointreau to jonah crab au gratin, chicken consommé to chilled midori melon soup, prime rib with horseradish popover to grilled swordfish with three-mustard sauce.

(607) 547-9931. Hawkeye Bar & Grill, entrées, $12.75 to $22. Lunch daily, 11:30 to 3; dinner, 5:30 to 9:30 , May-October. Closed Sunday and Monday and reduced hours in off-season.

Dining Room, lunch or brunch on Lakeside Patio, depending on weather, noon to 2; dinner nightly, 6 to 8:30; jackets required.

 The 1819 House
County Road 11 at Greenough Road, Cooperstown

Local consensus anointed the old Terrace Café as best in town during its heyday. Now relocated to a larger, more historic structure with a Greek-like pillared portico several miles south on a former hops farm, this enterprise seems to be a case of out of sight, out of mind. People mention it when prompted, but seldom volunteer it in their list of dining favorites.

Owner Robert Paul and Baltimore-trained chef Lynn Hathaway have maintained the Terrace’s culinary tradition in a trio of nicely restored upstairs dining rooms and a downstairs tavern with a stone fireplace. “We try to do things nobody else around here does,” says Lynn , citing particularly his seafood and veal dishes, including veal london broil with mushroom and red wine sauce, a specialty. Other unusual dishes on the extensive menu are sea scallops with mushrooms and parma ham en casserole, filet of catfish bayou stuffed with backfin crab, and shrimp and scallops thermidor.

If not exactly cutting-edge, Manhattan style, the fare has its moments, as in the tangy goat-cheese lasagna, layered with prosciutto and marinara sauce, a dish we found surprisingly refined, and the veal scaloppine sautéed with zucchini, tomatoes and pernod. The crab cakes and fried oysters rémoulade are favorite starters. The specialty dessert, bread pudding with a delicious whiskey sauce, is so rich that a little goes a long way. Ditto for the chocolate madness.

A tavern menu offers lighter fare.

(607) 547-1819. Entrées, $14.95 to $22.95. Dinner, Tuesday-Sunday 5 to 9 or 10.

 
Material excerpted from Inn Spots & Special Places / Mid-Atlantic,
by Nancy and Richard Woodworth. Copyright 2003.

Wood Pond Press
365 Ridgewood Road
West Hartford, CT 06107
Phone: (860) 521-0389
Fax: (860) 313-0185
© Copyright 2008
All rights reserved.

E-mail feedback to:
woodpond@ntplx.net

Home page | Full destination index |
About Wood Pond Press | Ordering Information | Restaurant of the Week | Inn of the Week |
Book of the Month | Getaway of the Month |