State College
Dining Spots

The Hummingbird Room
Route 45, Spring Mills

Arguably the area’s finest dining is offered by Eric and Claudia Sarnow in a National Register landmark country manor home built in 1847. The couple left Philadelphia, where he was sous chef for six years at the renowned Le Bec Fin after a three-year apprenticeship in France, to open a 22-seat Hummingbird Restaurant in the Woodward Inn in eastern Centre County in 1993. They purchased the Fisher House and moved the Hummingbird Room closer to State College two years later, retaining the name but expanding dinner service from three to five nights a week.

Dining is in a variety of small rooms on the first and second floors of a red brick Victorian with painted lady shutters. Burgundy-linened tables are set with stunning Villeroy & Boch china. Dishes arrive under silver cloches and tablecloths are crumbed between courses.

The French menu is available à la carte or prix-fixe, $37.50 for three courses. The reputation of the lobster bisque, the house-smoked salmon with a lobster and artichoke salad, the grilled Hudson Valley duck foie gras with two fruits and the sautéed lobster with morels over homemade pasta preceded our visit. Good things also were said about the filet of beef rossini with black truffle sauce and the loin of veal with smoked veal sausage, cognac sauce and truffled mashed potato.

We were smitten by the wild mushroom ravioli and the cold seafood pâté with lobster and salmon for starters. The roast duckling with raspberry sauce and the filet of pork tenderloin with dijon mustard-tomato-cornichon sauce and a goat cheese soufflé were superior main dishes. Claudia prepares the desserts, which include an excellent chocolate-hazelnut dacquoise, orange cheesecake with grand marnier, rhubarb cobbler and kiwi sorbet. Eric uncorked the Mount Nittany Vineyard & Winery champagne with a saber in the napoleonic style.

The upstairs bistro called The Nest offers casual dining (from pizzas and salads to steak frites) as well as jazz, blues and cocktails.

(814) 422-9025.  Entrées, $23.75 to $32. Dinner, Wednesday-Sunday from 5. Bistro, $4.50 to $16, 5 to midnight. 

 Zola New World Bistro
324 West College Ave., State College

Finally, a sophisticated, worldly bistro in downtown State College. After three years as executive chef at the Carnegie House here, Culinary Institute of America graduate Paul Kendaffy left in 2002 to open his own with-it place with David Fonash, a former sous chef and wine expert who grew up in State College.

Theirs is a large, high-ceilinged and nicely noisy restaurant with an open kitchen at the rear, a bar with high  tables and leather sofas, and white-clothed tables along the tall front windows and side walls. The latter are rust-colored and accented with hooked rugs and wall hangings. Votive candles flicker on the tables.

Chef Paul’s food is some of the most innovative found outside Pennsylvania’s largest cities. Adventurous diners are rewarded with changing treats ranging from crispy whole red snapper with a red chile and ginger sauce to pork tenderloin stuffed with pears and rosemary, sauced with cognac and mustard, and served with a honey-roasted sweet potato puree. Consider a menu that offers a choice of rare sesame-seed-crusted yellowfin tuna with port and ginger sauce, steamed chick pea dumplings with red chile beurre blanc and citrus couscous, and whole roasted foie gras with sautéed fruits and eighteen-year-old balsamic vinegar ($75 for two). There’s even a beluga caviar tasting appetizer to start the splurge.

We were quite taken with the tuna tartare, which arrived – stylishly but improbably – atop the base of an upside-down martini glass, dressed with a lime-cilantro vinaigrette and chive cream, and the steamed pumpkin dumplings laced with guava, peach and blackberry coulis. The Lyon-style salad with potato, curly endive, bacon and poached egg was superb. So was the entrée of free-range breast of duck and confit of leg, served with a creamy white bean ragoût. Desserts included vanilla crème brûlée, chocolate mousse and fruit sorbets,

From the olive and Italian breads that began the meal to the Rabbit Ridge zinfandel that we nursed to the end, here was a first-rate dining occasion.

(814) 237-8474. Entrées, $15 to $26. Dinner, Monday-Saturday 5:30 to 9 or 10.
 

The Gamble Mill Tavern
160 Dunlap St., Bellefonte

The first Bellefonte building to earn placement on the National Register, this three-story mill dates to 1785 as part of the earliest settlement in the Nittany Valley. The co-owners, self-taught chef Courtney Confer and manager Jeanne Murphy, started in 1986 with a soup and sandwich restaurant. Now the full-service facility heads most lists of favorite eating spots and includes a revolving art gallery.

Dining is on several levels in rooms of varying size. Tables are grouped in the cobblestone carriageway, where millstones are embedded on the floor. There are a tavern room of brick and wood, a loft-style dining area full of hanging plants, and a huge dining room for functions or overflow.

The mill is a sight to behold, both for its art and its history. The food measures up, as evidenced by our lunches of smoked salmon risotto, served with wilted spinach and tomato-basil vinaigrette, and a warm Polynesian chicken salad with avocado, melon and bell peppers in a fabulous orange-ginger dressing. Our tablemates liked their creole pasta, mesquite-grilled shrimp with black beans and roasted pepper salsa, turkey club croissant and char-grilled vegetable pita, although one was not happy with the Thai shrimp that was not at all Thai. Cappuccino torte and an ice cream puff were tasty desserts. Fans say the signature death by chocolate is to die for.

At night, the setting is elegant for Courtney’s ahi tuna with Asian dipping sauce, seafood strudel, grilled salmon caribe, crab cakes, chicken montrachet, mustard-crusted rack of lamb, and mixed grill of smoked duck breast and venison chop with dried fruit sauce. The wine list is small but choice and affordable.

(814) 355-7764. www.gamblemill.com. Entrées, $16.95 to $25.50. Lunch, Monday-Saturday, 11:30 to 2:30. Dinner, Monday-Saturday, 5 to 8.

 

La Bella Trattoria
1116 East High St., Bellefonte

This old-world restaurant beside and beneath the restored Garman Opera House theater opened in 2002 to a receptive audience, wooed partly, no doubt, by the offering of complimentary wine and beer. Artificial vines and grapes are twined around grotto-like dining rooms with stone walls, red-clothed tables and booths on two floors.

The menu promises a mix of Italian and “nouveau cuisine.” That translated to seven pasta offerings and half a dozen each of veal and chicken dishes, plus mussels marinara, garlic-encrusted salmon with creamy dill sauce, yellowfin tuna steak with tomato-basil-olive salsa, shrimp and scallop scampi, and filet mignon with mushroom-brandy cream sauce. Typical starters are crab and corn bisque, antipasti with meat and cheese, brandied mushrooms over crostini and smoked provolone with a hearty red sauce.

Cheesecake, cannolis and tiramisu are favorite desserts.

(814) 353-8808. Entrées, $12.99 to $19.99. Dinner, Tuesday-Saturday 5 to 8 or 9. BYOB.

Duffy's Boalsburg Tavern
113 East Main St., Boalsburg

Steaks and seafood are the specialties in this handsome stone building, a stage stop tavern dating to 1819. There’s a good variety of menu choices, served in both formal and informal surroundings with appropriate Colonial atmosphere.

The extensive Duffy’s Tavern menu is heavy on snack food, from “porridge of the day” (homemade soup) to a “Colonial sampler” of Buffalo-style wings, potato skins, mozzarella sticks and fried zucchini. Seven kinds of burgers and twice as many sandwiches and croissants are on the all-day menu. The tavern’s changing specials might be rainbow trout sautéed with a lemon-peppercorn sauce, grilled tuna steak with citrus butter, almond chicken and New York strip steak.

The formal Boalsburg Tavern menu is more elaborate, with offerings from bacon-wrapped sea bass with horseradish aioli to grilled lamb loin steak with rosemary jus. Lump crab cakes with sweet chili sauce and pan-seared elk ribeye steak with prosciutto-blue cheese sauce are other possibilities.

The 22-inch-thick stone walls are as solid as the day they were erected, keeping the interior temperatures a cool 68 degrees even in summer. The terrace is a favorite for outdoor dining in season.

(814) 466-6241. Entrées, $13.95 to $19.95. Lunch, Monday-Saturday 11:30 to 2. Dinner, Monday-Saturday 5 to 10. 

The Tavern Restaurant
220 East College Ave., State College

This ramble of rooms along the historic walkway, beside the Centennial Pig sculpture and just below the Penn State campus, is dark and historic with wood paneling, green and white tablecloths and all kinds of university memorabilia. It’s of the genre that students and nostalgic alumni love, and has been a State College fixture since its founding in 1948.

The menu, printed daily, features good old American fare with cajun and Italian accents. It lists spaghetti with marinara sauce for $7.95 and the optional Italian meatballs cost 95 cents each. Typical starters are shrimp cocktail, hot garlic and potato soup, clams casino, marinated herring and escargots. Main courses range widely from baked cod with sweet pepper and fennel sauce, sautéed sea scallops with mushrooms and wine, crab cakes and marlin steak with lemon-tarragon butter to chicken cordon bleu, German pot roast with red wine, veal parmesan and New York strip steak. The price includes as many choices from the old-fashioned vegetable and salad menu as one wishes. The vegetable platter – also an all-you-can-eat, unlimited selection – goes for a bargain $5.95.

The Tavern’s fans consistently vote it the area’s best restaurant.

(814) 238-6116. Entrées, $8.95 to $17.95. Dinner nightly, 5 to 10 or 10:30, Sunday to 8:30. 

 The Allen Street Grill
100 West College Ave., State College

Located above the busy Corner Room Restaurant, another Penn State institution, is this large and more contemporary retreat with a second-floor porch overlooking “The Wall,” a favorite campus gathering spot.

Where the Corner Room’s ultra-extensive menu is rather basic, the upstairs gets upscale in the collegiate idiom Main dishes include char-grilled grouper Mediterranean, balsamic maple-glazed salmon, chicken bordelaise and mixed grill. Pastas are interesting, as in tomato-vodka shrimp over orecchiette or fettuccine tossed with chicken, crab and sundried tomatoes.

Starters include coconut shrimp, crab and mango spring rolls, grilled portobello mushroom and a nacho platter billed as downtown’s biggest and best, enough for two or more to share. Carrot cake and chocolate mousse pie are the desserts of choice.

The Corner Room serves three meals a day. It began as Jack’s Road House in 1855, the year the agricultural predecessor to Penn State was founded. Both restaurants are in the landmark Hotel State College, most of whose original 70 rooms have been converted to apartments or shops.

(814) 231-4745.  Entrées, $12.95 to $21.95. Lunch daily from 11. Dinner, 4:30 to 10 or 11.

Material excerpted from Inn Spots & Special Places / Mid-Atlantic, by Nancy and Richard Woodworth. Copyright 2003.

Wood Pond Press
365 Ridgewood Road
West Hartford, CT 06107
Phone: (860) 521-0389
Fax: (860) 313-0185
© Copyright 2008
All rights reserved.

E-mail feedback to:
woodpond@ntplx.net

Home page | Full destination index |
About Wood Pond Press | Ordering Information | Restaurant of the Week | Inn of the Week |
Book of the Month | Getaway of the Month |